{
    "clean_result": false,
    "domain": "housing",
    "evasion_class": "rule_renaming",
    "federation_scope": {
        "fragmentation_detected": false,
        "missing_participants": [],
        "participant_reentry_checked": false,
        "participants_declared": 4,
        "participants_observed": 4,
        "person_registry_used": false
    },
    "fictional": true,
    "functional_equivalence": {
        "contract": "antichrist.cx.functional-equivalence-test.v1",
        "dimensions": {
            "derived_labels": {
                "evidence": "Synthetic control and replacement traces did not reproduce the retired adverse pathway on this dimension.",
                "status": "different"
            },
            "export_reimport": {
                "evidence": "Synthetic control and replacement traces did not reproduce the retired adverse pathway on this dimension.",
                "status": "different"
            },
            "human_note_instructions": {
                "evidence": "Synthetic control and replacement traces did not reproduce the retired adverse pathway on this dimension.",
                "status": "different"
            },
            "model_retraining": {
                "evidence": "Synthetic control and replacement traces did not reproduce the retired adverse pathway on this dimension.",
                "status": "different"
            },
            "new_vendor": {
                "evidence": "Synthetic control and replacement traces did not reproduce the retired adverse pathway on this dimension.",
                "status": "different"
            },
            "proxy_substitution": {
                "evidence": "Synthetic control and replacement traces did not reproduce the retired adverse pathway on this dimension.",
                "status": "different"
            },
            "queue_prioritization": {
                "evidence": "Synthetic control and replacement traces did not reproduce the retired adverse pathway on this dimension.",
                "status": "different"
            },
            "renamed_fields": {
                "evidence": "Synthetic canaries and operational traces reproduced the same prohibited consequence despite the changed label or placement.",
                "status": "equivalent"
            },
            "retention_cache_behavior": {
                "evidence": "Synthetic control and replacement traces did not reproduce the retired adverse pathway on this dimension.",
                "status": "different"
            },
            "subsidiary_fragmentation": {
                "evidence": "Synthetic control and replacement traces did not reproduce the retired adverse pathway on this dimension.",
                "status": "different"
            },
            "threshold_changes": {
                "evidence": "Synthetic control and replacement traces did not reproduce the retired adverse pathway on this dimension.",
                "status": "different"
            },
            "workflow_relocation": {
                "evidence": "Synthetic control and replacement traces did not reproduce the retired adverse pathway on this dimension.",
                "status": "different"
            }
        },
        "does_not_establish": "This fictional test does not establish prevalence, intent, culpability, or facts about any real institution or person.",
        "evasion_detected": true,
        "evidence_summary": "The renamed rule reproduced the same hold; the branch was disabled, prior effects were reversed, and recurrence canaries now pass.",
        "overall": "equivalent_harmful",
        "replacement_reproduces_prohibited_effect": true
    },
    "human_accountability": {
        "authority_can_change_mechanism": true,
        "independent_signatory": "Independent public-interest signatory (fictional)",
        "institutional_owner": "Collective-remedy enforcement owner (fictional)",
        "regulatory_escalation_owner": "Public accountability escalation officer (fictional)"
    },
    "independent_oversight": {
        "access_limits": [
            "Declared R50 observation window",
            "Synthetic and aggregated evidence before affected-person data",
            "No unrestricted person-level browsing"
        ],
        "access_revocation_risk": "Access may be narrowed by contract or technical control and must be reported as an evidence gap.",
        "access_status": "full",
        "affected_person_data_minimized": true,
        "authority_basis": "Time-bounded fictional monitoring mandate limited to institutional mechanisms and remedy enforcement.",
        "can_authorize_individual_adverse_action": false,
        "confidential_contest_route": "/contestability/",
        "conflicts_disclosed": [
            "No operational role in the fictional decision system",
            "No authority to issue individual adverse actions"
        ],
        "funding_boundary": "Funding may not depend on clean findings, enforcement volume, or person-level outcomes.",
        "monitor_name": "Independent public-interest monitor (fictional)",
        "observed_surfaces": [
            "policy_documentation",
            "production_rule_configuration",
            "decision_logs",
            "vendor_exports",
            "queue_priorities",
            "feature_model_lineage",
            "human_note_templates",
            "caches_retention",
            "downstream_reimport",
            "federation_participants"
        ],
        "organizationally_separate": true,
        "public_person_registry": false,
        "publishes_person_level_allegations": false,
        "publishes_person_level_scores": false,
        "synthetic_canaries": [
            {
                "canary_id": "CAN-R50-001-A",
                "contains_personal_data": false,
                "purpose": "Detect recurrence of the retired adverse effect without tracking an affected person.",
                "synthetic": true
            },
            {
                "canary_id": "CAN-R50-001-B",
                "contains_personal_data": false,
                "purpose": "Test downstream propagation and re-import behavior without a person registry.",
                "synthetic": true
            }
        ],
        "unobserved_surfaces": []
    },
    "individualized_action_firewall": {
        "eligibility_denial_from_pattern_prohibited": true,
        "oversight_may_authorize_adverse_action": false,
        "pattern_may_trigger_institutional_investigation_only": true,
        "person_level_risk_scoring_prohibited": true,
        "requires_accountable_human_review": true,
        "requires_contest": true,
        "requires_correction": true,
        "requires_event_specific_individualized_evidence": true,
        "requires_notice": true,
        "surveillance_targeting_from_pattern_prohibited": true
    },
    "institutional_change": {
        "after": "Resident consistency review",
        "before": "Adverse-record freshness gate",
        "change_flags": {
            "federation_fragmented": false,
            "model_changed": false,
            "name_changed": true,
            "participant_reentered": false,
            "proxy_changed": false,
            "vendor_changed": false,
            "workflow_changed": false
        },
        "change_type": "rule_renaming",
        "claimed_newness_is_not_proof": true,
        "claimed_purpose": "Simplify terminology after the collective remedy.",
        "declared_change_categories": {
            "documentary_operational_divergence": false,
            "model_retraining": false,
            "multi_vector_evasion": false,
            "oversight_access_loss": false,
            "participant_reentry": false,
            "proxy_substitution": false,
            "rule_renaming": true,
            "subsidiary_fragmentation": false,
            "vendor_transfer": false
        },
        "effective_at": "2026-09-02"
    },
    "integrity": {
        "input_sha256": "b81215e1f666df58b7f1bb31505bb724c9220596a100f6a0ae88bd357dbe8a1f",
        "output_sha256": "5ef2f02105e4b54a750a3cac3f89776d18333fb0367f750c99bac68e1abafbbc",
        "receipt_sha256": "113649fa45af37b1bf9aeed0d0774084700109198aef0ac2a6643acb972016f6"
    },
    "mechanism_map": [
        {
            "after": "Resident consistency review",
            "before": "Adverse-record freshness gate",
            "layer": "decision mechanism",
            "mechanism_id": "CRE-R50-001-M01",
            "observed_effect": "The renamed rule reproduced the same hold; the branch was disabled, prior effects were reversed, and recurrence canaries now pass.",
            "owner": "Institutional implementation owner (fictional)",
            "status": "replacement_active"
        },
        {
            "after": "R50 monitored downstream decision path",
            "before": "R49 remedy propagation obligation",
            "layer": "downstream enforcement",
            "mechanism_id": "CRE-R50-001-M02",
            "observed_effect": "Tracks whether the old adverse consequence remains operative after the institutional change.",
            "owner": "Downstream remediation owner (fictional)",
            "status": "replacement_active"
        }
    ],
    "observation_plan": {
        "absence_of_evidence_is_evidence_of_absence": false,
        "affected_person_data_minimized": true,
        "bounded": true,
        "declared_surfaces": [
            "policy_documentation",
            "production_rule_configuration",
            "decision_logs",
            "vendor_exports",
            "queue_priorities",
            "feature_model_lineage",
            "human_note_templates",
            "caches_retention",
            "downstream_reimport",
            "federation_participants"
        ],
        "known_limit": "The observation window and declared surfaces bound every conclusion.",
        "methods": [
            "synthetic canaries",
            "aggregated outcome traces",
            "configuration diffs",
            "confidential affected-person contest intake"
        ],
        "observed_surfaces": [
            "policy_documentation",
            "production_rule_configuration",
            "decision_logs",
            "vendor_exports",
            "queue_priorities",
            "feature_model_lineage",
            "human_note_templates",
            "caches_retention",
            "downstream_reimport",
            "federation_participants"
        ],
        "unobserved_surfaces": [],
        "window_end": "2026-12-31",
        "window_start": "2026-09-01"
    },
    "open_obligations": [],
    "promised_remedy": {
        "accountable_owner": "Collective-remedy enforcement owner (fictional)",
        "prohibited_effect": "No group pattern, proxy, cluster, or successor mechanism may become individual guilt, risk scoring, surveillance targeting, or eligibility denial.",
        "promise": "Retire stale-data holds and allocate correction without constructing a suspect-tenant cohort.",
        "proof_required": "Operational evidence that the prohibited effect stopped across every declared mechanism and downstream participant.",
        "r49_terminal_state": "redress_verified"
    },
    "r49_lineage": {
        "hash_scope": "whole source artifact bytes and canonical R49 receipt",
        "r49_receipt_id": "CPR-R49-001",
        "r49_receipt_sha256": "0d69a5878c2add635eaed07e1f8a3ab613dce8039e47f7d0b84d7ea6e796366c",
        "source_artifact": "data/collective-redress-r49.json",
        "source_artifact_sha256": "2a2252ca51226485f5517362092989a760c6a08deade1c8f120cb6eaa0154b52"
    },
    "receipt_id": "CRE-R50-001",
    "release": "R50",
    "remedy_effect": {
        "affected_pathways_checked": 10,
        "baseline_effect": "The R49 pattern or successor mechanism could produce an adverse consequence without individualized evidence.",
        "correction_persists": true,
        "downstream_use_operational": false,
        "old_effect_operational": false,
        "proof_summary": "The renamed rule reproduced the same hold; the branch was disabled, prior effects were reversed, and recurrence canaries now pass.",
        "replacement_effect": "The renamed rule reproduced the same hold; the branch was disabled, prior effects were reversed, and recurrence canaries now pass.",
        "synthetic_canaries_passed": 1
    },
    "schema": "antichrist.cx.collective-remedy-enforcement-receipt.v1",
    "state_history": [
        {
            "evidence": "Synthetic R50 evidence packet for baseline pinned.",
            "observed_at": "2026-09-02T12:00:00Z",
            "owner": "R50 lineage custodian (fictional)",
            "sequence": 1,
            "state": "baseline_pinned"
        },
        {
            "evidence": "Synthetic R50 evidence packet for mechanism mapped.",
            "observed_at": "2026-09-03T12:00:00Z",
            "owner": "Institutional mechanism auditor (fictional)",
            "sequence": 2,
            "state": "mechanism_mapped"
        },
        {
            "evidence": "Synthetic R50 evidence packet for replacement detected.",
            "observed_at": "2026-09-04T12:00:00Z",
            "owner": "Change-control reviewer (fictional)",
            "sequence": 3,
            "state": "replacement_detected"
        },
        {
            "evidence": "Synthetic R50 evidence packet for functional equivalence tested.",
            "observed_at": "2026-09-05T12:00:00Z",
            "owner": "Independent functional-equivalence lead (fictional)",
            "sequence": 4,
            "state": "functional_equivalence_tested"
        },
        {
            "evidence": "Synthetic R50 evidence packet for evasion detected.",
            "observed_at": "2026-09-06T12:00:00Z",
            "owner": "Independent public-interest monitor (fictional)",
            "sequence": 5,
            "state": "evasion_detected"
        },
        {
            "evidence": "Synthetic R50 evidence packet for proxy substitution tested.",
            "observed_at": "2026-09-07T12:00:00Z",
            "owner": "Proxy and feature audit lead (fictional)",
            "sequence": 6,
            "state": "proxy_substitution_tested"
        },
        {
            "evidence": "Synthetic R50 evidence packet for federation scope checked.",
            "observed_at": "2026-09-08T12:00:00Z",
            "owner": "Federation accountability lead (fictional)",
            "sequence": 7,
            "state": "federation_scope_checked"
        },
        {
            "evidence": "Synthetic R50 evidence packet for remedy effect observed.",
            "observed_at": "2026-09-09T12:00:00Z",
            "owner": "Independent outcome verifier (fictional)",
            "sequence": 8,
            "state": "remedy_effect_observed"
        },
        {
            "evidence": "Synthetic R50 evidence packet for evasion contained.",
            "observed_at": "2026-09-10T12:00:00Z",
            "owner": "Independent public-interest signatory (fictional)",
            "sequence": 9,
            "state": "evasion_contained"
        }
    ],
    "status_note": "Evasion occurred and was contained; this is not displayed as a clean history.",
    "summary": "A fictional housing institution renames a retired freshness rule, but synthetic applicants receive the same hold until the monitor detects and contains the workaround.",
    "terminal_state": "evasion_contained",
    "title": "Renamed rental screen reproduces the retired stale-data hold"
}